You Did What You Could
SEGMENT 5 · Soften and Forgive
EPISODE 2
You Did What You Could
You cannot ask your past self to know what only living through it taught you
Reflection
"I am so sorry," I said as I walked into the exam room.
She looked up at me over her glasses.
I was meeting her for the first time. She was in her eighties, no taller than five feet, but there was something about the way she looked at me that made me stand a little straighter.
"I am sorry," I said again as I walked to the sink to wash my hands.
She was still looking at me over her glasses.
I straightened my white coat like a soldier being inspected by a superior.
"Never say you are sorry. Never," she said.
I was used to patients reacting when I ran late, but no one had ever responded like this. I stepped closer to the computer and placed my fingers on the keyboard. Before I could begin, she continued.
"Explain why you are late. And if needed, say you apologize. You hear me?" she said.
"Yes, ma'am."
Something about her Southern drawl pulled the "Yes, ma'am" out of me before I had time to think about what she had just said.
"They used to call us sorry little girls in Alabama," she continued. "And you are definitely not a sorry little girl."
I stood a little straighter.
"Now, why did you keep me waiting?"
Before I could answer, she added, "And stick with the truth. It will serve you well."
I explained why I was late.
Then I said, "I apologize."
She nodded.
"Do better next time."
For the next thirty minutes, she questioned every decision and made me earn the white coat I was wearing.
I never saw her again.
But she left me with a question I have carried ever since: What is wrong with saying I am sorry?
I Am Sorry
There is nothing wrong with saying I am sorry, I thought. We say it to express regret, tenderness, sympathy, remorse. Maybe we say it because we think those are the words another person needs to hear.
But the woman from Alabama made me notice something about the words themselves.
"I am sorry" begins with "I am." And that "I am" can quietly turn "I did something wrong" into "there is something wrong with me."
"I made a mistake" cab become "I am a mistake."
"I failed" can become "I am a failure."
For her, "I apologize" placed the attention on the action and what she would do about it.
She wanted me to understand the difference between examining what I did and condemning who I was.
She wanted me to take responsibility without becoming trapped in shame.
When What You Did Becomes Who You Are
Shame can begin with something that is true.
I hurt someone.
I made the wrong choice for myself.
I should have handled that differently.
But then the story changes.
I am a terrible person.
Something is wrong with me.
This is who I am.
The action becomes an identity.
And once we believe that story about ourselves, looking honestly at what happened becomes harder.
We defend. We explain. We hide.
Sometimes we replay what happened again and again, as though suffering over it long enough will somehow make it right.
But condemning yourself is not the same as taking responsibility for your actions.
You can say, I did that. It caused harm. I wish I had chosen differently, without turning what you did into the definition of who you are.
When You Know the Ending
Hindsight gives us something we did not have when we were living forward.
The ending.
And the ending makes the signs that came before it look obvious.
The comment you dismissed becomes the warning you should have noticed.
The relationship you stayed in becomes the one you should have left.
The promise you made to quit smoking becomes, I should have stopped sooner.
The opportunity you walked away from becomes the one you should have held onto.
And so we ask: Why didn't I know? Why did I stay? Why didn't I stop sooner?
But you are asking those questions knowing how the story turned out. You are judging yesterday's decisions with today's understanding.
That is the unfairness of hindsight.
What Did You Know Then?
This does not mean every choice you made was the best choice. Some were not.
Maybe you hurt someone. Maybe you broke someone's trust. Maybe you stayed too long, or left too soon. Maybe you acted out of anger, fear, jealousy, or pride. Maybe your intentions were good. Maybe they were complicated. Maybe they were not good at all.
What you did still mattered.
Understanding your past is not about making everything you did acceptable. It is about seeing the whole person who made the choice.
How old were you? Who was around you? What did you understand about love, loyalty, success, or duty? What were you afraid of losing? What support did you have? What had life not taught you yet?
You cannot give your twenty-year-old self the lived experience of your forty-year-old self.
Some of what you know today exists precisely because of what happened yesterday.
And many times, you had to make the mistake to learn what only the mistake could teach you.
Now comes the harder part: forgiving yourself for making it.
This Is Where Forgiveness Becomes Complicated
If I stop replaying what I did and blaming myself for it, am I letting myself off the hook? If I stop feeling guilty, does that mean I did not care enough?
Regret can make us believe that feeling bad is a form of taking responsibility. So we replay what happened. We imagine saying the right thing, leaving earlier, noticing what we missed. We imagine a different ending.
But replaying the past keeps us asking, What if?
Responsibility asks a different question: What can I do now?
Maybe you can apologize, tell the truth, or repair what you can.
Maybe you cannot.
A relationship may not return. An opportunity may be gone. Someone may forgive you and still walk away.
Then responsibility becomes accepting what you cannot change and changing what you can.
Yes, I did that.
I wish I had chosen differently.
Now I know differently.
The past does not need more of your suffering.
It needs what you have learned from it.
And you need to forgive the person who did not yet know what you know now.
You need to begin again.
Self-Forgiveness Is Not an Excuse
If we forgive ourselves, do we become less accountable?
No.
Self-forgiveness does not deny what happened. It means accepting it honestly without making it the definition of who you are.
Think about how you would respond to a friend who made a mistake.
Would you keep reminding them of what they did?
Or would you tell them the truth, help them learn from it, and still believe they could begin again and do better?
So why not offer yourself that same humanity?
You can regret what happened without becoming what happened.
You can know differently now and choose from that knowing.
What Do You Know Now?
The woman from Alabama did not spend our visit making sure I felt bad enough for being late.
She asked what happened.
She asked for the truth.
Then she asked me to learn from it.
Do better next time.
I understand the wisdom in that differently now.
She did not erase my responsibility.
She gave it somewhere to go.
Forward.
So ask yourself: What do you know now that you did not know then?
Maybe you know that love does not require you to abandon yourself. Maybe you know that when your body tells you something is wrong, you need to listen. Maybe you simply know that you never want to make that choice again.
Whatever you know now, let it change what you do next.
Tinfash Practice: Look Back Without Looking Away
Bring to mind something from your past that you still hold against yourself.
Notice what you say to yourself about it.
I should have known.
I should have done better.
What was wrong with me?
Pause. Take a breath.
Instead ask:
What did I know then?
What do I know now?
Is there anything I can still repair?
Do not use the answers to put the person you were back on trial.
Use them to guide the person you are becoming.
Closing
There is courage in looking back with forgiveness.
There may be things you wish you could undo. People you wish you had treated differently. Choices whose consequences you still carry.
Self-forgiveness does not ask you to call any of it good.
It asks you to see what happened, take responsibility for what was yours, and stop asking the person you were to know what you know now.
You knew what you knew then. Now you know differently.
Let your life show what you have learned.
Pause before reacting. Listen. Speak when you need to speak. Apologize when you need to apologize. Repair what you can. Accept what you cannot.
Your choices today cannot change what happened yesterday.
But they can shape what happens tomorrow.
That is where self-forgiveness begins.
Not when the past no longer matters, but when you stop asking how long you must suffer for it and start asking how you want to live because of it.
And when we stop putting the person we were on trial, we may finally have room to grieve what it cost us.
The journey continues in Episode 3: Grieving the Old Self.
A Mantra to Carry
I did what I knew then. I know differently now.
Use this when the old questions arrive, the why didn't I knows and the what was wrong with mes.
Say it quietly.
Let it separate who you were from who you are becoming.
Journal Invitation
Write by hand.
Bring to mind a choice from your past that you still hold against yourself.
Write down exactly what you have been telling yourself about it. Do not soften it for the page.
What did you know then, before you knew how the story would end?
What had life not yet taught you?
What were you afraid of, or trying to protect, when you made that choice?
Is there anything left to repair? Or is this something to accept as it is?
What do you know now that you did not know then?
Do not write this to defend yourself.
Write it to see the whole person who made that choice, not just the ending they could not yet see.
Meditation
With that, we begin our healing connection.
Embrace the journey. Keep listening. Healing knows the way.
Love and more love,
Dr. Kidi
More reflections at drkidi.com · Follow @drkidi.healing · Guided meditations on YouTube @drkidi · Short stories on Substack @drkidi
Comments